Clean or Condemn? A Case Study:

& Which Components Are Worth Cleaning 🚛

Quick Answer:

Clean an emissions component when inspection shows an intact substrate/brick that has soot, ash, or even crystallized DEF.

Condemn it when the substrate is cracked or melted, the cells are hard-packed, or flow stays in the red range after cleaning.

Cleaning can’t repair a coolant-poisoned DOC, and it won’t last unless you fix whatever caused the upstream problem. In the example below, a CEM packed with crystallized DEF was cleaned, which could have saved a local fleet over $8,000 vs. a brand-new replacement unit.

DPF Cleaning Guide: Inspection & Benchmarking

The $8,600 Decision: A Case Study

Picture an emissions unit pulled off a machine, packed solid with crystallized DEF. It looks hopeless, and a new one lists at over $8,600*. Most of us would order the replacement. A lumber company did.

By the time the original unit reached Diesel Emissions Service (DES) in Redding, CA, the new one was already bought. The DES crew baked the clogged CEM three times in a Filtertherm oven, and the DEF came out. The cleaning bill was about $600.

On the one hand, the customer now has a spare unit. On the other hand, they now know they didn’t need to spend the extra $8,000.

The costly step in this story was a question nobody asked: can it be cleaned? Here’s how to answer that for your own fleet, including which emissions components are worth cleaning in-house and which belong in the recycle bin.

*Dealer list price for the Cat® Clean Emissions Module at the time of publication. Prices vary by dealer and platform.

What Came in and What the Borescope Showed

The unit was a Cat® CEM (Clean Emissions Module), an all-in-one housing that combines the aftertreatment stages in one enclosed assembly. A welded-together unit like this one can’t be easily opened, so the main inspection tool is a borescope. The camera showed thick, heavy crystallized DEF built up inside the unit. A dosing fault was the likely cause, though the exact failure on this unit wasn’t confirmed.

Borescope screen before and after cleaning

The crew baked the unit in a Filtertherm thermal oven. Heavy deposits or soot loads can take more than one cycle, and this one took three. Each bake runs overnight. After the third, the borescope showed the DEF deposits were cleared.

Why This Matters for On-Road Fleets

The Cat module is an off-road part, but the situation applies to any fleet with newer trucks. Nearly every modern diesel uses DEF, and many now pack the aftertreatment components into a single assembly similar to this Cat CEM.

The Detroit One Box found on many Freightliner trucks is one of the most common examples – while some parts are serviceable on these, others are not. When something inside fails, often the first answer from the dealer is to replace the whole assembly, and a Detroit One Box can run $12,000 or more. That should be the last resort.

A DEF or other upstream issue will also affect many other shapes and styles of diesel emissions system components, including DPFs, DOCs, and SCRs. Filtertherm Cleaning systems excel at cleaning these types of filters as well.

DEF issues causing crystallization are another reason cleaning is required. Our technicians point to several causes:

  • A doser or injector malfunction.
  • Outside air pulled in through a bad gasket.
  • Loose bolts on the assembly.
  • A pinhole or crack in a DEF hose.

Any of these can spray DEF where it shouldn’t be, and it crystallizes inside the unit, often making a hell of a mess.

FYI: Filtertherm thermal ovens are large enough to hold most One Box units or bake multiple standard DPFs at once. And we’ve got an even larger version in the works. Stay tuned…

While most filter cleaning services are due to normal soot buildup over time, the “replace-or-clean” question applies here too.

Clean or Condemn: A Decision Guide

Inspect first, then decide. An initial visual inspection for cracked or melted bricks is step one, plus performing a “pin-test” to spot-check cells for hard-pack sintering/soot buildup. Weigh and flow test every standard filter before and after each cleaning (use a borescope on welded units).

What you find in an emissions component, what it looks like, and whether to clean or condemn it
What you findWhat it looks likeVerdict
Soot and ash loading High backpressure, and flow readings return to the green range after cleaning Clean and return to service
Crystallized DEF deposits Visible crystalline buildup or a unit that weighs far more than normal Clean, possibly in several bakes. Fix the cause first.
Coolant contamination Coolant traces in the unit from an engine leak Clean only as a short-term stopgap. The DOC coating is likely poisoned, and cleaning can't repair it.
Cracked, melted, or damaged substrate Visible cracks or broken sections. Sections melted from a thermal event. Condemn. Don't clean or reinstall.
Hard-packed cells Flow stays in the red range after multiple cleanings Condemn

The complete pre/post inspection protocol is detailed here > DPF Cleaning Guide: Inspection & Benchmarking.

For standard filters, the flow rate chart sorts readings into three bands: green for excellent, orange for okay but due for more frequent cleaning, and red for damaged or compromised. A filter that reads red after a proper cleaning should be replaced. Get the DPF Flow Chart PDF here.

Fix the Cause First section image

Fix the Cause First

The lumber company’s unit came back clean. A second similar unit came in, from a different company. It had a different story. It was contaminated with coolant and soot. One thermal cleaning and a dry-out cycle got it working, but the coolant likely poisoned the catalyst coating in the DOC, and no amount of cleaning can restore that. The owner kept the cleaned unit as a stopgap and ended up ordering a replacement anyway.

Both cases teach the same lesson. Cleaning removes what’s inside the unit. It doesn’t remove whatever put it there. A leaking coolant path, upstream engine issues, or a faulty doser will foul a freshly cleaned unit again, so find and fix the source before you reinstall anything.

Replacement Cost vs. In-House Cleaning:

Doing the Math

The $600 in this case is what DES charged a customer for 3 cleanings, so it isn’t your in-house cost. Your replacement cost is time and labor. Each thermal bake runs overnight, and the hands-on work is loading the oven, unloading it, and inspecting the unit afterward. Labor varies by shop and by how many bakes a unit needs. This one needed three – which isn’t normal – most of the time one bake is all it takes.

Set that against the alternative. The replacement cost for this unit lists at over $8,600*, and the same trade-off applies to any assembly your fleet would otherwise replace. If a few overnight bakes and a technician’s time come in well under the price of a new part, cleaning in-house pays for itself on that unit alone. Filtertherm systems can make sense for fleets of all sizes, where enough components cycle through to keep the oven busy.

We built a custom Fleet ROI Tool so you can run some numbers based on your fleet’s DPF maintenance needs.

Tools to Run Your Own Numbers

  • Filtertherm ROI Tool: a custom ROI calculator for fleets. Use it to compare in-house cleaning with your current costs.
  • DPF Flow Rate Chart: a 14-page reference of baseline, operational, and compromised flow readings for filters from Caterpillar, Cummins, Detroit, Volvo, Mack, International, and other makes. Flow test with the inlet side up. Readings can vary by up to 0.3″ w.g. with temperature, humidity, and altitude.

More guides live on the Filtertherm Resources page.

Key Takeaways

  • Ask around. See if a part can be cleaned before you order a replacement. A lumber company bought a unit that lists at over $8,600 when the original could be restored in three overnight bakes.
  • Inspect first: check for a cracked or melted substrate/brick, run a pin test, weigh and flow test filters, and use a borescope on welded units.
  • Crystallized DEF can often be cleaned out. Heavy deposits may take several bakes.
  • Condemn units with a cracked or melted substrate, hard-packed cells, or flow in the red range after cleaning.
  • Cleaning can't restore a DOC that coolant has contaminated.
  • Find & fix the cause before you reinstall: check the doser, gaskets, bolts, DEF hoses, upstream leaks, etc.
  • In-house cleaning can make sense for many fleets. You control the maintenance process and save money over time. The ROI Tool can help you run the numbers.

About Filtertherm

Filtertherm makes DPF cleaning systems for fleets that want to clean in-house. To talk through your fleet’s numbers, or to confirm whether a specific unit fits the oven, call 888-792-2922 or start with the ROI Tool.

Call: 1-888-792-2922

Email: info@filtertherm.com

Take Control of Your Fleet's DPF maintenance with Filtertherm!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can crystallized DEF be cleaned out of an emissions component?

A: Often, yes. Thermal cleaning can remove crystallized DEF, and heavy deposits may need more than one bake. The unit in this case study took three cleaning cycles due to the enclosed structure and large amount of DEF inside.

Q: How do I know if a component can be cleaned?

A: Inspect it first. Check for a cracked or melted substrate, run a pin test on the cells to spot hard-packed soot or sintering, and weigh and flow test standard filters before and after each cleaning. Use a borescope on welded units. Cracks, broken sections and hard-packed cells that keep flow in the red range mean replace it.

Q: What causes DEF to crystallize in the first place?

A: Our technicians point to a doser or injector malfunction, outside air through a bad gasket, loose bolts and pinholes or cracks in DEF hoses.

Q: Will cleaning fix a coolant-soaked DOC?

A: No. Cleaning removes soot and deposits, but it can’t restore a DOC’s coating that coolant has damaged. A unit in that condition is a short-term stopgap at best.

Q: What should I check before reinstalling a cleaned unit?

A: Find and fix the source of the problem first: the doser or injector, gaskets, bolts, DEF hoses or any upstream coolant or oil leaks. A cleaned unit that goes back on a truck with the original issues unfixed will just foul again.

Q: How long does a thermal cleaning take?

A: A typical thermal bake cycle runs overnight. This includes warm up and cool down times in addition to the bake cycle. The Filtertherm Cooling Cart can speed up the cool down period by a few hours. Heavy DEF deposits can take several bakes.

Q: Can a Detroit One Box unit go in a Filtertherm oven?

A: Filtertherm ovens are large enough to take most One Box units. See oven specs to confirm the fit for your specific unit. We have something even larger in the works. Stay tuned.

Q: How many trucks does it take for in-house cleaning to make sense?

A: Filtertherm systems can pay for themselves relatively quickly. It depends on how many trucks are in your fleet, how often the filters need cleaning and how much you’re currently paying for 3rd party cleaning service. The ROI Tool can help you run your own numbers.

Key Terms

  • DEF (diesel exhaust fluid): a solution of urea and deionized water sprayed into the exhaust to reduce NOx.
  • SCR (selective catalytic reduction): the stage that uses DEF to convert NOx into nitrogen and water.
  • DPF (diesel particulate filter): the filter that traps soot and ash from the exhaust.
  • DOC (diesel oxidation catalyst): a catalyst that oxidizes hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide in the exhaust stream.
  • CEM / One Box: an all-in-one aftertreatment housing that combines several of these stages in one assembly. CEM is Cat’s Clean Emissions Module. One Box is Detroit’s version.

Get the Premier DPF Cleaning solution for your FLEET.

Give us a call. Get Answers.

Use our ROI tool to see how quickly this investment can save your fleet time and money. Financing is now available. Check it out!

Call or email to schedule a meeting with our expert Sales Team. Nadjara would be happy to help you.